Recurrence of expiation with a recurrence of the violation of fast
Recurrence of expiation with a recurrence of the violation of fast

Book:

The book of Fasting - كتاب الصيام

Chapter:

Breaking the Fast and Not Fasting and the Ahkam

Section:Violations of the Fast
Topic/Issue:3036 - Recurrence of expiation with a recurrence of the violation of fast --
Agreement:They agreed that person who has sexual intercourse during Ramadhan and makes an expiation, and then has intercourse on another day, has to make another expiation. They also agreed that the person who commits intercourse number of times on same day, is only obliged to make a single expiation.
Opinions:
Opinion FromOpinionExplanation
Imam Malik,Imam ShafiHe is to make expiation for each dayIts not similar to hadd. They maintained that the distinction is based upon expiation being a way of attaining nearness to Allah, while the hudd are a form of pure deterrence.
Imam Abu HanifaHe is to the make single expiation as long as he has not made an expiation for the first intercourseSimilar to hudud. just as the person committing unlawful sexual intercourse is subjected to one penalty of stripes even if he has committed the act a thousand times (before that) when he has not been subjected to /hadd for any of those occasions.
Tags :Worship, Fasting, Breaking Fast, Violations,Expiation, Breaking Fast, Recurrence
See Also:Is expiation obligatory for intentionally breaking the fast by eating or drinking?
The person fasting has sexual intercourse out of forgetfulness
The woman who has been coaxed into having sexual intercourse (while fasting)
Is there an order for expiation?
References:1[pg:358]
Last Updated:2011-02-21

<< Back to List of Issues
Please Help Us Spread the Word. Press LIKE.