Which Type is Better
Which Type is Better

Book:

The Book of Hajj - كتاب الحج.

Chapter:

Rites

Section:Types of Hajj
Topic/Issue:3531 - Which Type is Better --
Opinions:
Opinion FromOpinionExplanation
Imam MalikIfradNarration of Aisha. Abu Umar ibn Abd al-Barr said: "Ifrad as performed by the Prophet (Gods peace and blessings be upon him) was reported by Jabir ibn Abd Allah through various channels that are mutawatir and authentic"
They argued by way of reason that tamattu and Ifrad are prescribed as exemptions, because of which atonement (a blood sacrifice) has been made obligatory in them.
Others:
abd allah ibn umar, Ibn abbas, ibn al-Zubayr, ATamattuNarration of Ibn Umar. Imam Ahmad said: "I have no doubt that the Messenger of Allah (Gods peace and blessings be upon him) was a Qarin, but tamattu is dearer to me. He argued for choosing tamattu based on the words 'If I were to start off again, I would not drive the sacrificial animals, and I would change it to (umra)'
OthersQiranNarration of Umar and Narration from Marwan and narration of Anas. They argued, based on the narration of Aisha that it is known that he (Gods peace and blessings be upon him) had the sacrificial animals with him, and it is unlikely that he should order the person who had his sacrificial animal to perform qinin, and then not perform Oran himself when he had the sacrificial animals
Evidences :Hadith of Aisha, Hadith of Ibn Umar, Hadith of Abu Huraira, Hadith of Marwan, Hadith of Anas, Hadith of Aisha [Hide/Show]
Tags :Worship,Rites,Types
References:1[pg:395]
Last Updated:2011-03-12

<< Back to List of Issues
Please Help Us Spread the Word. Press LIKE.